John 5:31–38
We begin today a new series exploring the words of the prophet Jeremiah,
and we do so not because Jeremiah makes for comfortable reading,
but because in an age like ours,
we need prophets who speak difficult truths.
The lectionary leads us today not to Jeremiah’s call or visions of judgement,
but instead to a lesser-known episode
—a dramatic and disturbing tale
of political power trying to silence a prophetic word.
It is, in many ways, a story as old as time:
the uncomfortable word is spoken, the powerful are threatened,
and someone tries to burn it all down.
But, as we shall see,
the word of God is not so easily destroyed.
Let’s begin with the story.
Jeremiah is, by this point in his life,
effectively banned from entering the temple precincts.
His message has become too much.
The powers that be have silenced him—at least in person.
But it turns out that the word of God
doesn’t require a pulpit to be preached.
And so Jeremiah turns to Baruch, his scribe and co-labourer,
and dictates the whole of his prophetic message
—years of proclamations, warnings, visions, and pleas—
onto a single scroll.
It is painstaking work. It is dangerous work.
And it is deeply hopeful work.
“Perhaps,” says Jeremiah, “when the people hear of all the disasters
that the Lord intends to bring upon them…
perhaps then, they will all turn from their evil ways.” (v.3)
And we hear in this not the glee of a prophet enjoying judgment,
but the plea of one who longs for repentance, for change, for mercy.
And so, in a dramatic moment of holy subversion,
Baruch takes the scroll and goes to the temple to read it aloud.
It’s worth pausing here to name the risk:
this is a scribe and a prophet, confronting the king and the court
not with swords, but with words.
It is an act of hope, but also of defiance.
Eventually, word of this subversive public reading reaches King Jehoiakim.
The scroll is retrieved, and brought into the king’s presence.
He’s sitting in his winter palace
—warm, comfortable, and secure.
And thus the scene is set: the king reclines before a brazier,
a fire gently crackling, as Jehudi begins to read.
But then the horror begins.
As the scroll is read, the king takes a penknife and slices off the columns
—three or four at a time—and throws them into the fire.
This is no mere distraction.
This is not a bored monarch playing with parchment.
This is a calculated rejection. This is theological violence.
What we witness here is the wilful destruction of a prophetic word.
Jehoiakim does not argue with the scroll, nor debate it.
He just burns it.
This is the ancient world’s version of censorship,
of banning books, of silencing dissent.
It’s not just an act of political convenience;
it is a spiritual rejection of the voice of God.
But here’s where the story refuses to end.
Jehoiakim may burn the scroll, but he cannot silence the word.
God tells Jeremiah: write it again.
Take another scroll. Dictate every word once more.
And add to it a new word of judgment
against the king who dared to destroy the first one.
So what does this tell us?
Maybe we hear that the word of God is not fragile.
It may be ignored, resisted, even burned—but it is never destroyed.
This is a theme that resonates throughout scripture:
The bush that burns but is not consumed.
The Word made flesh, crucified but raised.
The Spirit that speaks through silenced mouths.
And so, here in Jeremiah, the prophetic word is rewritten.
The hope of repentance remains.
The judgment deepens. And the call continues.
Which brings us to our second reading, from John’s Gospel.
Here we find Jesus in dialogue with his critics
—those who question his authority, his message, and his identity.
And once again, we see a pattern emerge:
the word of God is spoken, and yet it is not believed.
Jesus speaks of testimony
—the testimony of John the Baptist,
of the works he performs,
and of God the Father.
“You search the scriptures,” he says later in this chapter,
“because you think that in them you have eternal life;
and it is they that testify on my behalf.
Yet you refuse to come to me to have life.” (John 5:39–40)
These are haunting words.
The people who know the scriptures best
do not recognise the Word made flesh when he stands before them.
Like Jehoiakim, they hear but do not listen.
Like the king, they would rather silence the Word than let it confront them.
When Jesus speaks of testimony in John 5,
he is not simply listing credentials.
He is inviting his hearers to see the divine continuity
between the prophets of old
and his own witness in the present.
There is to be heard in Jesus’ words,
a profound resonance with Jeremiah’s experience.
The people of his time, too, have heard the voice of God in their midst
—but they do not receive it. They do not recognise it.
And so we see a troubling pattern:
Jeremiah's scroll is burned.
Jesus’ body, the living Word, will be crucified.
Later, the early church’s message will be driven underground,
scattered by persecution.
But again and again, the word re-emerges
—resurrected, unquenchable, alive.
In John’s Gospel, Jesus describes his own works
as signs of divine testimony.
Just as Baruch’s scroll carried Jeremiah’s oracles,
so Christ’s actions and presence carry the very words and will of God.
But to recognise this—to truly hear it—
requires something more than external validation.
As Jesus says, “his word does not abide in you,
because you do not believe him whom he has sent.” (John 5:38)
This is not merely a failure of intellect,
but a failure of imagination, of faith, of willingness.
The issue is not that the evidence is lacking
—it’s that the heart is resistant.
Here is the deep spiritual challenge for us today:
Are we open to hearing the Word
when it comes to us from unexpected places?
Are we prepared to receive the testimony of Christ
when it disturbs our comfort?
Jeremiah’s scroll, Jesus’ ministry,
and the prophetic voice in our own generation
all carry the same invitation: not just to hear, but to turn
—to repent, to change, to live differently.
So let’s return now to the fire in Jehoiakim’s chamber.
There are two kinds of fire in this story.
One is the fire of destruction
—the fire of censorship, of silencing, of domination.
This is the fire in the king’s brazier.
But there is another fire, a different fire.
The fire of God. The fire of prophecy.
The fire of Pentecost.
Jeremiah speaks elsewhere of this fire:
“Is not my word like fire, says the Lord,
and like a hammer that breaks a rock in pieces?” (Jer. 23:29)
The fire of God’s word does not consume
—it purifies. It refines. It ignites.
At Pentecost, it does not destroy the disciples
—it empowers them.
And at Bloomsbury, this is the fire we seek
—not the fire that burns scrolls, but the fire that burns in our hearts.
The fire that warms, illuminates, and inspires.
There is something deeply significant
about the physicality of the scroll in Jeremiah’s story.
It is not just symbolic—it’s tactile.
It can be held. It can be cut. It can be burned.
But the Word of God is never confined to ink and parchment.
We who are heirs to the Reformation
have sometimes reduced scripture to a static text
—to be analysed, explained, and controlled.
And yet Jeremiah’s story reminds us
that the word is not a dead letter. It is a living voice.
When King Jehoiakim burned the scroll,
he thought he was silencing the message.
But God’s word had already taken root
—in Baruch, in Jeremiah, in the hearers at the temple gate.
The scroll was not the Word
—it was merely its vehicle.
We need this reminder today.
Because the Bible can become a weapon when treated as lifeless text.
It can be misquoted to justify injustice.
It can be marshalled to oppress.
But when we treat scripture as living, breathing Word
—always moving, always speaking,
always calling us deeper into love, justice, and mercy—
we find ourselves drawn into transformation.
This is why Jesus can say in John’s Gospel
that his critics “search the scriptures” but still miss the life it offers.
They knew the text, but not the voice.
And so the question returns to us:
Are we treating the Bible as a static artefact
or as a living conversation with God?
Are we open to the Spirit’s fresh breath moving through the familiar words?
Do we encounter the fire of the Word as it kindles new life in us,
or do we reach for the penknife?
If Jehoiakim saw the scroll only as a threat to his power,
we are invited to see it as an invitation
to a deeper, more radical discipleship
—a call to repentance, yes, but also to justice, peace, and hope.
And so this story asks hard questions of us.
Because we are not just Jeremiah or Baruch.
Sometimes, we are Jehoiakim too.
We all have our penknives.
We all have moments when the word of God comes too close,
too uncomfortably,
and we are tempted to slice it away.
And in our world, prophetic voices are still being silenced:
Voices calling for racial justice are dismissed as divisive.
Calls for climate action are framed as extremist.
Pleas for Palestinian dignity are labelled dangerous or antisemitic.
The witness of LGBTQ+ Christians is often burned before it is ever heard.
Jehoiakim lives on wherever power fears truth.
Wherever the prophetic word is deemed too threatening to tolerate.
But Baruch also lives on
—wherever courageous scribes, preachers, and communities
speak the truth again, and again, and again,
even when it is rejected.
So how, then, do we become people who listen rightly?
Who welcome the word of God even when it arrives
uninvited, uncomfortable, or disruptive?
First, we must cultivate what the spiritual tradition calls holy listening.
Holy listening is not passive;
it is active attentiveness to the voices that challenge us.
It is choosing to remain open to a word
that we did not write, and may not like.
At Bloomsbury, we already know the importance of this:
In our commitment to interfaith conversation,
we practise listening to the divine word
spoken in the lives and experiences of others.
In our community organising, we listen for the cries of the poor,
the marginalised, and the excluded.
In our inclusive theology,
we have listened to those the church has too often silenced.
All of this is prophetic. All of this is faithful.
To listen well is to allow the Spirit to speak in unexpected ways,
through unexpected voices.
Baruch was not a prophet—he was a scribe.
And yet his reading of the scroll
became a proclamation of divine judgment and hope.
Likewise, the voices we are tempted to overlook
—those without official titles, credentials, or authority—
may yet speak with the fire of God.
And so we must keep our ears open and our penknives sheathed.
We must resist the temptation to excise, edit, or explain away
the parts of scripture—or of testimony—that unsettle us.
Because it is in those very moments
that the Spirit may be speaking most clearly.
So what kind of community are we called to be?
Here at Bloomsbury, we are not called to be a comfortable court
gathered round a fire, editing the gospel for our own peace of mind.
We are called to be scribes of justice.
Voices of compassion. Prophets of inconvenient truth.
We are called to take the scrolls others burn and write them again.
To speak the truth that was silenced.
To read aloud the words that power tried to hide.
We are called to let the word of God abide in us
—not just in our minds, but in our actions, our politics, our relationships.
And we are called to let that word take flesh in us,
as it did in Christ.
In a world of political spin and theological censorship,
the story of Jeremiah 36 reminds us
that the word of God is not so easily extinguished.
It may be torn up, cut down, thrown into fire
—but it rises again, rewritten, re-spoken, re-lived.
The question for us is this:
Will we be the ones who feed the flames of censorship?
Or will we be the ones who carry the fire of truth?
Will we slice away the parts of scripture that challenge us?
Or will we let the whole word abide in us, even when it burns?
The scroll may burn, but the word of God endures.
The prophet may be silenced, but the voice of God returns.
The Word became flesh—and the light shines in the darkness,
and the darkness did not overcome it.
May that Word abide in us.
May we speak it, live it, and never be afraid to write it again.
Amen.