+ New post

Friday, 20 November 2026

Swords into Ploughshares

A Sermon for Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church

Sunday 22 November 2026 



Isaiah 36.1–3, 13–20;  37.1–7; 2.1–4; Matthew 5.14


It's good to be home.


Two weeks ago, while Liz and I were in the West Bank, the church kept Remembrance Sunday here. Today, on the last Sunday of the church's year, we come to Reign of Christ Sunday and Isaiah's vision of swords beaten into ploughshares. I've spent the last fortnight in a land where swords are very much still swords, and I've come back wanting to ask what that vision means, and whether we can still believe it.


So we've brought the Violinist out again. Some of us will remember him. He sits with his bow raised, lost in the music, and he's made entirely of guns.


Look closely and you can still see what he used to be. Every piece of him was once a weapon in Mozambique's civil war, which ran from the late 1970s until 1992 and cost close to a million lives. When the peace accord was signed, the guns didn't go away. Millions of them were buried in gardens and hidden in roofs, waiting.


So in 1995 the Christian Council of Mozambique, led by the Anglican Bishop Dinis Sengulane, started a project called Transforming Arms into Tools. People could bring in a rifle and take home a sewing machine, a bicycle, a hoe. One village handed in five hundred weapons and was given a tractor. The bishop used to say that keeping a gun in your bedroom is like sleeping next to a snake: sooner or later it turns and bites you.


Most of the guns were destroyed. But some went to artists in Maputo, who cut them apart and welded them into something else – thrones, trees, animals, people. Somebody took the tools of a war that had taught a whole generation to kill, and made a violin player. Isaiah imagined swords becoming ploughs, something useful. The artists went one better and imagined them becoming music.


Hold on to that, because this morning's readings start somewhere much darker.


Jerusalem is surrounded. The Assyrian army, the superpower of its day, has swept through Judah taking city after city, and now the king's spokesman stands outside the walls and starts to talk. Notice who he talks to. Not the king, and not the king's officials. He shouts up to the ordinary people on the wall, in their own language, so every soldier and water-carrier can hear. It's psychological warfare, and it's very good.


His argument is simple. Look at the record. Hamath, Arpad, Sepharvaim, Samaria. Did any of their gods save them? Then why would yours? History belongs to the strong, and the strong are us. Power is its own proof.


Then he does something clever. He offers peace. "Make your peace with me and come out to me; then every one of you will eat from your own vine and your own fig tree" (Isaiah 36.16). That's the language of the prophets' dream – every family safe under its own vine and fig tree, with no one to make them afraid. The empire has stolen the vocabulary of peace. But there's a catch in the next verse: "until I come and take you away to a land like your own land." The vine and the fig tree are on offer only until the march into exile begins.


Empires have always talked like this. Every empire calls its order peace; the Romans stamped the word on their coins. It's peace on the conqueror's terms – quiet, because nobody dares to speak. Last week in Jerusalem, Daniel from the reconciliation ministry Musalaha put it to us plainly: to the powerful, peace means dialogue and friendship; to the weak, it means justice and liberation.


Hezekiah's response is an entirely human reaction. He tears his clothes, puts on sackcloth and goes into the house of the Lord. He has no answer. He sends word to Isaiah: "children have come to the birth, and there is no strength to bring them forth" (37.3). Anyone who's sat with the news these last few years knows that feeling.


But Isaiah replies: "Do not be afraid because of the words that you have heard" (37.6). Not the army – the words. Empire's first weapon is the story it tells about what's inevitable.


Because lectionaries make choices, our reading this morning ends at verse 7 of chapter 37. Read on, and the story tells of the angel of the Lord striking down 185,000 Assyrians in the night, and Sennacherib murdered by his own sons back home (37.36–38). Deliverance, in that telling, looks like more violence – just bigger, and on our side. Sennacherib's own inscriptions tell it differently. He boasts of shutting Hezekiah up in Jerusalem like a caged bird, and the book of Kings admits that Hezekiah paid him a fortune in tribute (2 Kings 18.14–16).


We shouldn't hurry past that. The Bible isn't one flat voice. It's a long conversation in which the character of God comes slowly into focus, and in places the old belief that God saves by out-killing our enemies is still very much alive. Scripture is where that belief is gradually exposed and unpicked, until in Christ it's undone altogether.


And look what sits at the very front of the same scroll. In Isaiah 2 the nations aren't struck down. They're walking uphill.


"Many peoples shall come and say, 'Come, let us go up to the mountain of the Lord … that he may teach us his ways'" (2.3). They come as students, not conquerors. God settles their disputes. And then the line we know: "they shall beat their swords into ploughshares, and their spears into pruning-hooks; nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more" (2.4).


Neither shall they learn war any more. War is learned. Nobody is born knowing how to hate the people over the hill. It's taught – by example, by story, by fear handed from parents to children, by grievance answered with grievance. We learn our desires and our rivalries by copying one another, and violence is the thing we copy most readily of all. One blow invites the next, and every side can name the wound that justifies its own.


So it matters that in Mozambique some of the people taking the guns apart were young men who'd once been made to carry them as child soldiers. They'd been taught war. Now, rifle by rifle, they were unlearning it with their hands.


It matters, too, that Isaiah's image is so physical. Beating a sword into a ploughshare isn't a switch we flick. It takes heat, and a hammer, and a long time at the anvil, and the metal resists. The prophet Joel knew the lesson can run the other way – he calls the nations to "beat your ploughshares into swords" (Joel 3.10) – and most of human history has run in Joel's direction. Remembrance Sunday, at its best, stands with Isaiah: it grieves the dead so that we'll stop making more of them. The danger is always that remembering slides into Joel's recruiting call.


I want to say something about where we've been, and I want to say it carefully, because this is a sermon and not a party political broadcast, and because many of us carry this part of the world close, from many different directions.


Jerusalem is the city in our reading, threatened then by Assyria. It's still a city where the hopes and fears of more than one people meet, and it's easy to read Isaiah 2 as a map for whichever side we're on. But Isaiah's mountain is precisely not the place where one nation finally wins. It's the place where all the nations come to learn – and the first thing they learn is to put the weapons down.


On our second day we were in Silwan, just below the walls of the Old City, in a neighbourhood called Al-Bustan. It's earmarked to become a park, King David's Garden. We met Fakhri, who leads the local community there. His house was demolished in 2024, and he's been living in a mobile home among the rubble. He told us: "We are not against anyone who wants to live alongside us and with us, but we are opposed to people who want to live instead of us." A week after we met him, he was ordered to demolish what was left of his house himself, and last Sunday he did. When we left, he was expecting the bulldozers to come for the mobile home.


None of it is lawless. It happens through permits, courts and orders, the whole respectable machinery of the state. In the book of Isaiah, the spokesman outside Jerusalem offered every family its own vine and fig tree, until the march into exile. In Al-Bustan the garden is real, and it's being planted where people's homes were.


What we heard again and again was the spokesman's logic from Isaiah 36: that security comes only through dominance, that the strong write history, that the other side understands nothing but force. That logic isn't owned by any one people. It lives in every empire and every frightened nation, our own included, and it's wearing everyone down. We grieve with Israeli families who lost loved ones on 7 October 2023, and whose fear is real. We grieve with Palestinian families in Gaza and the West Bank, whose losses are beyond counting. Grief for one never needs to cancel grief for the other. About a third of our travelling group were Jewish. And here in London, our grief for Palestinians must sit alongside our respect for our Jewish neighbours, many of whom carry their own grief and fear.


We also met two young Israelis who have decided not to join the army. They described schools where the army is everywhere: children write letters to serving soldiers and talk about which unit they'll join. One of them put it like this: "You are told that you are the light and they are the darkness." Refusing has cost them friends, family support and future jobs. One said that in saying no, she felt she was betraying everything she grew up on. Both were quick to say that what they face is a fraction of what Palestinians face.


And yet the scriptures hold before us a dream: Neither shall they learn war any more. These two young adults had been taught war from childhood, and they're unlearning it at real cost.


And then on a hilltop farm between Bethlehem and Hebron, surrounded by settlements, Amal told us her father's last words to the family: never give up hope, never answer with violence. "If we knew tomorrow was the end of the world, we would go outside and plant an olive tree."


Today is Reign of Christ Sunday. It's a young festival, as these things go. It began in 1925, seven years after the Armistice, while the nations of Europe were still burying their dead and nationalism was rising again. It was a protest: Caesar isn't king, the nation isn't king – Christ is.


But we need to be careful what kind of king we mean, because the church has a long history of lending Christ's crown to empires. Matthew tells us what kind. When they came to arrest Jesus, one of his friends drew a sword and struck out, and Jesus said, "Put your sword back into its place; for all who take the sword will perish by the sword" (Matthew 26.52). Hours later he was crowned with thorns, robed in mockery and enthroned on a cross, with his title nailed over his head. That was the coronation.


The Assyrian spokesman asked which god had ever saved anyone from the strong. The cross is God's answer, and it isn't the one he expected. God doesn't turn out to be a bigger Sennacherib. God is the one who takes the full weight of our violence and doesn't hand it back. And on the third day God raises the victim – not to take revenge, but to return to the friends who ran away, with peace on his lips. The resurrection is God's verdict on the whole cycle. Christ isn't one more victory in the long war. He's the end of it. That's what it means to call him King: not that he has the biggest army, but that his kind of power, the power that will not kill, is the one that lasts.


Which brings us to the single verse from Matthew. "You are the light of the world. A city built on a hill cannot be hid" (Matthew 5.14).


Jesus grew up in Nazareth. A few miles away, on a hilltop, stood the city of Sepphoris. When he was a small child, Roman troops burned it after a revolt and sold its people into slavery; then Herod Antipas rebuilt it as a showcase for the new order. Some think Jesus could see it from his village. A city on a hill, built on the ashes of the last rebellion, gleaming with the empire's peace. And the hill’s story didn’t end there. Until 1948 it was home to a Palestinian village, Saffuriya, of around five thousand people. They were driven out that summer, the village was demolished, and a Jewish farming village was built on its land. Some of its refugees ended up in Nazareth, within sight of the hill they were driven from.


And on another hillside, to a crowd of fishermen and farmers and people who'd come because they needed healing, Jesus says: you are the city on the hill. Not the temple mount, not Herod's showcase, not a fortified capital – you. Isaiah's mountain, where the nations come to learn something other than war, turns out to be a people. A few verses earlier: "Blessed are the peacemakers" (5.9). A few verses later: "Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you" (5.44). That's the curriculum the nations climb the mountain to learn, and Jesus says we're where it's taught. Those young Israelis had been told that they were the light and their neighbours the darkness. The light Jesus speaks of can't work like that, because the same sermon tells us to love our enemies. It isn't defined against a darkness made of other people.


Not because we're especially good at it. But because this is what Christ's reign looks like on the ground: small communities in ordinary places where war is quietly being unlearned. A church at the top of Shaftesbury Avenue isn't much of a hill. But people from a great many nations have come through our doors over the years, some of them fleeing wars we only read about. Whenever a fear is laid down here, or an enemy is prayed for, the city on the hill is giving its light.


So let's come back to our friend who is still playing his music before us this morning.


What strikes me most about the Violinist is that he doesn't hide what he was. We can still see the gun in him. The artists didn't melt the past down and pretend it never happened. They took it and made it play.


That's what resurrection is like. When the risen Jesus meets his friends, he still bears the marks of the nails. The violence done to him is visible – and it's been transformed into the sign of peace.


That's the reign we celebrate this morning. Its fullness is still to come, but it isn't a dream reserved for the end of time. It has already begun. The King has already refused the sword. The tomb is already empty. In Mozambique and in Bethlehem and on Shaftesbury Avenue, swords are already being beaten – slowly, under the heat and the hammer – into ploughshares and pruning-hooks, and sometimes into violins.


The nations rage, and the empires make their speeches from outside the walls. But Christ is King, and his kingdom outlasts every one of them. That's the music we've been given. And by God's grace, we're learning to play it.

Monday, 26 October 2026

Solomon's Wisdom

A Sermon for Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church
Sunday 1 November 2026


1 Kings 3.4–28
Matthew 6.9–10
 
If you could have one wish –
          just one –
          what would it be?
 
Children go for a pony
          or a million pounds.
Adults get cagier,
          and try to wish for more wishes.
 
But underneath the game is a serious question:
          what would we really ask for,
          if we could have anything at all?
 
Solomon gets asked that question by God.
          'Ask what I should give you.'
It comes in a dream at Gibeon.
 
He doesn't ask for wealth,
          or long life,
          or the life of his enemies.
 
He calls himself a little child
          who doesn't know how to go out or come in,
and he asks for an understanding mind –
          or, as the older translations put it more literally,
          a listening heart –
to govern God's people
          and to tell good from evil.
 
It's a lovely answer.
          But it's worth noticing where it comes in the story.
 
The chapter before this one isn't lovely at all.
          David dies,
          and Solomon's first acts as king are a series of killings.
 
His older brother Adonijah,
          who had a decent claim to the throne,
          is executed.
Joab, David's old general,
          is cut down while he's clinging to the altar.
Shimei is killed on a technicality.
 
And the chapter closes:
          so the kingdom was established in the hand of Solomon (1 Kings 2.46).
 
Then chapter three opens with a marriage alliance with Pharaoh –
          the king of Egypt,
          the empire Israel's whole story began by escaping.
 
So when Solomon tells God
          he hasn't asked for the life of his enemies,
          there's an irony in it.
He doesn't need to ask.
          He's already taken them.
 
None of us comes to God from a clean place,
          and God meets Solomon there anyway.
 
The dream comes to a man
          who's made himself secure by the sword,
and God offers him another way to rule:
          not by the sword,
          but by listening.
 
 
Then, as if to test whether the gift has taken,
          the story hands him a case.
 
Two women come and stand before the king.
          The text calls them prostitutes.
They aren't named,
          and they have no one to speak for them.
 
One of them tells the story.
          We live in the same house,
          just the two of us.
I had a baby,
          and three days later she had one.
In the night her son died,
          because she lay on him.
 
She got up at midnight
          and took my son from beside me while I slept,
          and laid her dead son at my breast.
 
In the morning I went to feed my child
          and he was dead –
but when I looked at him in the light,
          he wasn't the son I'd borne.
 
And the other woman says,
          no –
          the living one is mine,
          and the dead one is yours.
And they go back and forth in front of the king.
 
This isn't a riddle.
          It's poverty and exhaustion and grief,
          and a shared bed in a crowded room.
 
One of these women has woken to find her baby dead
          and is out of her mind with it.
The other has had her child taken from her side.
 
There are no villains in a house like that –
          only people the world has left
          with nothing but each other to fight over.
 
And notice that they get in –
          the last people we'd expect to stand before a king –
          and he hears them out.
 
Then he does something careful.
          He says their claims back to them:
this one says,
          'The living son is mine and the dead one is yours',
and that one says,
          'No, your son is the dead one and mine is the living.'
 
That's what a listening heart sounds like:
          it gives back what it's heard.
 
 
And then the king says,
          'Bring me a sword.'
 
Imagine standing in that court.
          The young king who came to the throne over his brother's body
          has called for a weapon,
and the thing he means to use it on
          is a baby.
 
'Divide the living boy in two;
          give half to one,
          and half to the other.'
 
We've turned this into a figure of speech.
          'Splitting the baby' is what we call it
          when a negotiation ends
          with each side getting half of what it wanted.
 
But in the story it isn't a compromise.
          It's the logic of every sword.
 
When two claims collide
          and nobody can tell who's right,
make it equal
          by destroying the thing they both want.
 
Each gets half.
          Nobody gets anything.
 
Whether Solomon ever meant it,
          the text doesn't say.
What it tells us is what happens next.
 
 
One of the women cries out.
          The text says her compassion for her son burned within her –
          and the word for compassion there is related to the word for womb,
so this is a love felt in the body.
 
'Please, my lord, give her the living boy;
          certainly don't kill him!'
And the other says,
          'It shall be neither mine nor yours;
          divide it.'
 
There it is.
          One woman would rather lose the child than see him die.
          The other would rather the child die than lose.
 
That second voice is rivalry in its purest form:
          if I can't have it,
          neither will you.
 
René Girard saw in this story
          two kinds of sacrifice side by side.
One woman is ready to sacrifice the child
          in order to win.
The other is ready to sacrifice her own claim –
          her own heart –
          so that the child can live.
 
Girard said she was as perfect a picture of Christ
          as could be imagined.
A prostitute,
          in a story told to make a king look good.
 
And here's something easy to miss.
          We're never told which woman gave birth to that boy,
          and the king doesn't need to know.
 
'Give the first woman the living boy,' he says.
          'Don't kill him.
          She is his mother.'
 
She's his mother
          because she's the one who'd let him go
          to keep him alive.
 
Motherhood, in this story,
          isn't settled by biology or by possession.
It's recognised in love
          that is willing to lose.
 
That's good news for those of us
          who've parented children we didn't bear,
          or loved children we couldn't keep,
          or been parented by people who weren't our biological parents.
 
So Solomon's wisdom wasn't the trick with the sword –
          the oldest tool kings have.
It was in recognising self-giving love
          when it stood in front of him,
and putting the whole weight of the throne behind it.
 
A listening heart heard the difference
          between the cry that says 'let him live'
          and the cry that says 'divide it',
and gave the child to the first.
 
 
That's what we ask of our courts,
          and it's a live question this autumn.
 
The Courts and Tribunals Bill
          passed its third reading in the Commons on 13 October
          and has gone to the Lords.
 
Most of the headlines have been about juries,
          but another clause sits right alongside this story.
 
It removes from the Children Act
          the presumption that a parent's involvement in a child's life
          is for the child's good.
 
It was meant to protect children's relationships with both parents,
          but survivors of domestic abuse have shown
          how it was also used by abusive parents to keep their hold –
          on children,
          and through them on former partners.
 
The law is catching up with what this story already knew:
          a claim on a child isn't the same as love for a child,
and when the two pull apart,
          the child's life comes first.
 
Some of us know this not from the papers
          but from our own lives –
          from family courts,
          from contact arrangements,
          from fights over children that seemed to go on for ever.
 
Nobody's pain should be turned into an illustration.
          But this ancient story does insist on one thing:
God isn't on the side of whoever has the strongest claim.
          God is on the side of the child,
          and of the one who loves the child enough to let go.
 
 
The story of Solomon doesn't end there.
          Read on through 1 Kings
          and the listening heart slowly turns into something else.
 
The temple is built with forced labour –
          thirty thousand men conscripted from across Israel (5.13).
 
Silver becomes as common in Jerusalem as stones,
          horses and chariots are imported from Egypt,
          and there are seven hundred wives (10.27–29; 11.3).
 
Deuteronomy had warned that a king mustn't multiply horses,
          or wives,
          or silver and gold (17.16–17),
and Solomon manages all three.
 
The young man who asked for a heart to hear his people
          ends up building an empire on their backs.
 
After his death they come to his son and say,
          your father made our yoke heavy (12.4),
and the kingdom splits in two.
 
The sword that was put down in chapter three
          comes back in the end.
 
Wisdom asked for at the beginning
          isn't the same as wisdom kept.
Power has a way of turning a listening heart deaf.
 
 
Which may be why,
          when Jesus teaches his disciples to pray,
          he doesn't teach them Solomon's prayer.
 
Matthew's Gospel has its eye on Solomon:
          a few verses later Jesus says
          that Solomon in all his glory
          wasn't clothed like the wild lilies (6.29).
 
And the prayer he gives us
          begins a long way from the throne room:
'Our Father in heaven,
          hallowed be your name.
          Your kingdom come.
          Your will be done,
          on earth as it is in heaven.'
 
Here at Bloomsbury,
          when we pray this prayer together,
          we don't usually begin with 'Our Father'.
We say 'Loving God in heaven'.
 
We've done that for the best part of a decade,
          because we want the words we use for God,
          and for one another,
either to step beyond gender
          or to use it evenly.
 
Some of us find that a relief.
          For others, 'Father' is the word
          that has carried their faith for a lifetime,
and setting it aside
          can feel like losing something close.
 
Both of those are true in this room,
          and this isn't a contest that one side has to win.
 
Solomon's court may help us here.
          The woman the king called mother
          wasn't recognised by her claim,
          or by biology.
She was recognised by a love
          that would let go rather than see the child harmed.
 
When Jesus teaches us to call God 'Father',
          that's the kind of parent he has in mind:
not ownership or control,
          but care that gives itself away.
 
For some of us 'Father' says that perfectly.
          For others,
          because of the fathers we've had
          or the ways the word has been used,
it doesn't,
          and 'Loving God' says what Jesus meant more clearly.
 
Either way we're praying to the same God,
          the one we've just sung about,
          mother and father of us all,
who's always more than any name we bring.
 
Your name, not ours.
          Your kingdom, not ours.
          Your will, not ours.
The prayer begins by letting go of our claim.
 
It's the prayer of the woman in Solomon's court
          rather than the prayer of the king:
give it to her,
          only let the child live.
 
And it's prayed together.
          Whichever words we begin with,
          the prayer is plural all the way through –
give us,
          forgive us,
          lead us.
 
We aren't rivals at this prayer.
          Whoever stands next to us
          has exactly the same claim on God as we do,
which is no claim at all,
          and every right to be there.
 
 
Solomon's kingdom was established by the sword.
          The kingdom Jesus teaches us to pray for
          comes another way.
 
At the end of Matthew's Gospel,
          Jesus stands before a different court.
The governor's wife sends word
          that she's suffered much in a dream
          because of this innocent man.
 
Solomon listened to his dream;
          Pilate doesn't listen to hers.
 
He washes his hands in front of the crowd
          and hands over to the sword of empire
          the one person in the room
          who has claimed nothing for himself.
 
He's the child under the sword,
          and he's the love that lets go.
 
And on the third day
          God gives the verdict Solomon gave:
give him back,
          alive.
 
The resurrection is God's judgment
          on the logic of the sword.
The living one isn't divided.
 
 
Which brings us to this table.
          In a few moments we'll break bread,
          and that breaking is nothing like the sword in Solomon's court.
 
The sword divides to settle a rivalry:
          half to you,
          half to me,
          and nothing for anyone.
 
Bread is broken so that it can be shared,
          and the more it's broken
          the further it goes.
 
At this table nobody has a better claim than anybody else.
          We don't come because we've won.
 
We come empty-handed,
          like Solomon in his dream,
          like the woman who gave her claim away,
and what we receive isn't half of anything.
          It's the whole of Christ,
          given to each of us
          and to all of us at once.
 
So we don't come here as rivals,
          and we don't have to establish anything by our own hand.
 
The wisdom we asked for at the start of this service
          is a listening heart,
          given rather than earned –
given here,
          in bread broken and a cup poured out,
by the God whose name we hallow
          and whose kingdom is already breaking in among us.
 
The sword has been put down.
          The living one is not divided.
 
And he's been given to us –
          to all of us,
          together,
          and whole.

Monday, 19 October 2026

You Are the Man

A Sermon for Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church
Sunday 25 October 2026

 
2 Samuel 11.1–5, 26–27; 12.1–9
Psalm 51.1–9
Matthew 21.33–41

There’s a line in Hamlet
         that every theatre company knows by heart.
 
The prince is convinced
         his uncle has murdered his way to the throne,
         but he can’t prove it,
so he has the travelling players perform a play
         that mirrors the crime.
 
“The play’s the thing,” he says,
         “wherein I’ll catch the conscience of the king.”
 
Spending time recently over the road at the Shaftesbury Theatre,
         where I’ve become their Theatre Chaplain,
I’ve come to think this is one of the oldest truths of theatre.
 
A story gets past defences
         that an argument never could.
 
We sit in the dark, guard down,
         and then the lights come up
         and we realise the story was about us all along.
 
Shakespeare wasn’t the first to know it.
 
Nearly three thousand years ago
         a prophet called Nathan walked into the court
         of the most powerful man in Israel
         carrying nothing but a story,
         and he caught the conscience of a king.
 
 
Let’s go back to the start.
 
The author of 2 Samuel sets the scene:
         “In the spring of the year,
         the time when kings go out to battle” (2 Samuel 11.1).
 
It’s the season for kings to lead their armies,
         but this year the king has stayed at home in Jerusalem
         and sent Joab instead.
 
The shepherd boy who once faced Goliath
         now sends others to do the dangerous work.
 
Then the rooftop.
 
David strolls on the palace roof
         and sees a woman bathing.
 
Listen to the verbs that follow.
 
David sent and enquired.
         David sent messengers.
         He took her.
 
Sent, sent, took:
         the verbs of power.
 
When the people had first demanded a king,
         Samuel warned them what kings do: they take
— your sons, your daughters, your fields,
         the best of everything (1 Samuel 8).
 
And here is Israel’s best king,
         the man after God’s own heart,
         doing precisely that.
 
And we need to say something about Bathsheba,
         because the church hasn’t been kind to her.
 
Preachers have long cast her as the temptress.
         But the text says nothing of the sort.
 
She was purifying herself,
         as the law required (11.4).
 
Contrary to Leonard Cohen,
         the text doesn’t put her on the roof;
         it puts David there.
 
And when the most powerful man in the nation sends for you,
         what choice is there?
 
That isn’t romance.
         It’s an abuse of power,
         and many would rightly call it rape.
 
Bathsheba gets one line of her own,
         sent to the king:
         “I am pregnant.”
 
It’s the truth David now has to manage.
         And manage it he does.
 
He calls Uriah back from the front,
         hoping he’ll sleep with his wife
         so the child can pass as his.
 
But Uriah the Hittite —
         a foreigner, an outsider in Israel’s army —
         proves more faithful than the king.
 
He won’t go home
         while his comrades sleep in the open field,
         not even when David gets him drunk.
 
So David writes to Joab:
         put him where the fighting is fiercest,
         then pull back.
 
And Uriah carries his own death warrant,
         sealed,
         back to the battle.
 
It works.
 
Uriah dies,
         along with other soldiers whose names we’re never told.
 
David brings Bathsheba into the palace,
         she bears a son,
and as far as the court is concerned
         the matter is closed.
 
Except the narrator adds one line.
 
“But the thing that David had done
         displeased the Lord” (11.27).
 
That’s all.
         It’s almost quiet.
 
But it means somebody saw.
 
What the palace had agreed not to see,
         God saw.
 
 
So how do you speak truth to a king?
 
Everyone at court must have known or guessed.
         Joab knew; he’d carried out the order.
 
And no one said a word,
         because that’s how courts work.
 
Power surrounds itself with people
         who’ve learned that their safety
         depends on not noticing.
 
Nathan doesn’t arrive with an accusation.
         He arrives with a case for the king to judge.
 
There were two men in a certain city,
         one rich and one poor.
 
The rich man had very many flocks and herds.
 
The poor man had nothing
         but one little ewe lamb,
         which he’d bought and raised.
 
It grew up with his children.
         It ate from his plate
                  and drank from his cup
         and slept in his arms,
                  and it was like a daughter to him.
 
And when a traveller came to visit the rich man,
         he couldn’t bring himself to take from his own flock,
so he took the poor man’s lamb
         and served that instead.
 
David’s anger burns.
 
“As the Lord lives,
         the man who has done this deserves to die” (12.5).
 
He’ll pay it back four times over.
 
It’s a magnificent piece of royal outrage.
         David the just judge,
                  champion of the poor,
         defender of the little lamb.
 
And then Nathan says four words.
 
“You are the man.”
 
There’s real craft in this.
 
Had Nathan come in with an accusation,
         David’s defences would have been up
                  before the sentence was finished —
         it was wartime, soldiers die.
 
But the story slips under the guard.
 
By the time David sees who the rich man is,
         he’s already convicted himself
         out of his own mouth.
 
What’s striking is how easily David finds his outrage,
         so long as the villain is somebody else.
 
He still cares about justice —
         out there,
         in a story about a rich man in a certain city.
 
What he can’t do
         is see it in himself.
 
That’s how self-deception works.
 
We rarely lie to ourselves outright.
         We just arrange the furniture of our minds
         so that certain things stay in shadow.
 
 
But this isn’t a sermon about private guilt,
         a finger wagged along the pews.
 
Nathan is speaking to a king.
 
His parable is about what the powerful take from the powerless,
         and how a whole system closes ranks
         around the taking.
 
We’ve seen that pattern
         in public inquiry after public inquiry:
those who raised the alarm disbelieved or investigated,
         those who’d been harmed kept in the dark,
         an institution’s good name put ahead of the truth.
 
And the question that follows our anger
         is always Nathan’s:
         who is the man? Who is really to blame here?
 
It’s rarely just one person.
 
Usually there’s a whole culture
         that has learned not to notice.
 
And sadly, churches aren’t immune.
 
Some of the worst stories of recent years
         have been of churches protecting the powerful
while those who’d been harmed were told to keep quiet
         for the sake of the gospel,
         and ours isn’t a tradition with a clean record.
 
So Nathan’s question comes to us too:
         who, in the structures we belong to,
         are we not seeing?
 
Whose lamb has been taken
         while we found it easier not to look?
 
 
Jesus tells his own story in today’s gospel,
         and it’s no accident who he tells it to.
 
Matthew sets it in the temple,
         in the days after Jesus has overturned the tables.
 
The chief priests and the elders
         have just demanded to know by what authority
         he’s doing these things (Matthew 21.23).
 
And Jesus answers them as Nathan answered David —
         with a story.
 
A landowner plants a vineyard —
         anyone who knew Isaiah 5
         would hear the song of God’s vineyard here —
and the landowner leases the vineyard to tenants
         and goes away.
 
At harvest he sends servants for his share of the fruit,
         and the tenants beat one,
         kill another,
         stone another.
 
He sends more;
         they do the same.
 
Finally he sends his son.
 
But the tenants see the heir and think:
         kill him and the inheritance is ours.
 
So they throw him out of the vineyard
         and kill him.
 
Then Jesus does a very Nathan-like thing.
 
He turns to his listeners
         and asks them to judge.
 
“When the owner of the vineyard comes,
         what will he do to those tenants?”
 
And they answer:
         “He will put those wretches to a miserable death,
         and lease the vineyard to other tenants” (21.41).
 
Just like David.
 
Asked to judge the story,
         they reach straight for death.
 
And just like David,
         they haven’t yet realised
         they’ve been hearing themselves described,
         and are passing judgment on their own behaviour.
 
A few verses later Matthew tells us the penny dropped:
         they realised he was speaking about them (21.45).
 
That instinct isn’t confined to the first century.
 
Earlier this month the US Defense Secretary, Pete Hegseth,
         announced that Nidal Hasan,
         who murdered thirteen unarmed soldiers at Fort Hood in 2009,
         is to be executed by firing squad in December —
and that the execution would be livestreamed.
 
It would have been America’s first public execution
         in almost a century.
 
‘People need to understand’, Hegseth said,
         ‘that there are serious consequences’.
 
It now looks like the livestream will not go ahead,
         although the execution will,
but the announcement itself tells us something.
 
We need to tread carefully here, of course,
         because thirteen people were killed.
 
And one survivor, Alonzo Lunsford, shot seven times,
         told the BBC he wants Hasan to look him in the eye
         and know he failed.
 
But the question for us, this morning, is: where is God in this?
 
Certainly God is with Alonzo Lunsford,
         and nothing in the gospel asks us to look away
         from what was done to him.
 
But where is God if a man is shot by firing squad
         as millions watch?
 
Or as a man is executed as millions don’t watch,
         but follow it online?
 
Where was God when the recent botched execution of Christa Pike
         was reported in real time around the world?
 
The issue here isn’t whether the murders were monstrous;
         of course they were.
 
It’s what the spectacle is for,
         and whom it serves.
 
A firing squad on a screen, or a news feed,
         gives back no one who was lost.
 
What it does is gather a crowd around a victim,
         unite us in following the enacted violence,
and reassure the powerful
         that their verdict is righteous.
 
And we’ve seen this before.
 
Crucifixion was Rome’s livestream.
 
It happened in public,
         by the roadside,
                  outside the city wall,
         precisely so that everyone would understand
                  there are serious consequences
                  for defying the empire.
 
That’s where the tenants take the son in Jesus’ story:
         out of the vineyard, outside, to be killed —
just as Jesus himself would be,
         outside the city wall.
 
The cross was state violence
         staged as a lesson for the watching crowd.
 
And that is where God was —
         not among the watchers, but on the cross.
 
And notice that in Matthew
         it isn’t Jesus who supplies that violent ending.
 
His hearers do —
         the instinctive human answer.
 
And our reading stops right there, at verse 41,
         the human verdict hanging in the air
         as though it were the end of the story.
 
But it isn’t.
 
Jesus goes straight on, quoting the psalm:
         “The stone that the builders rejected
         has become the cornerstone” (21.42).
 
He doesn’t endorse their verdict;
         he points beyond it.
 
When the tenants did kill the son,
         outside the city wall, on a cross at Golgotha,
God’s answer wasn’t a miserable death for the wretches.
 
God’s answer was resurrection:
         the rejected one raised,
not to take revenge,
         but to become the cornerstone of something new.
 
 
So back to David,
         and to the psalm that tradition places in his mouth
         after Nathan’s visit.
 
“Have mercy on me, O God,
         according to your steadfast love…
Wash me thoroughly from my iniquity,
         and cleanse me from my sin.
For I know my transgressions,
         and my sin is ever before me” (Psalm 51.1–3).
 
That’s what honest repentance sounds like.
 
No excuses about wartime.
         No “mistakes were made”.
 
To his credit, David doesn’t argue with Nathan.
         “I have sinned against the Lord,” he says
         (2 Samuel 12.13).
 
It’s the beginning of seeing.
 
But one line in the psalm needs care.
         “Against you, you alone, have I sinned” (51.4).
 
Really?
 
What about Uriah?
         What about Bathsheba,
         and the soldiers who died beside Uriah?
 
There’s a kind of repentance
         that turns entirely towards God
and conveniently away from the people we’ve harmed —
         making it all about my soul and my standing with heaven,
         but never quite getting round to the victim.
 
Nathan won’t allow that.
 
His parable keeps the poor man and his lamb
         at the centre of the frame.
 
And the God of the Bible is, again and again,
         the God who stands with the one who’s been wronged.
 
So yes, to sin against Uriah is to sin against God —
         but precisely because God is with Uriah.
 
The way back to God
         runs through the people we’ve harmed,
         not around them.
 
And here’s a quiet, wonderful thing.
 
Matthew’s family tree of Jesus includes this story:
         “David was the father of Solomon
         by the wife of Uriah” (Matthew 1.6).
 
Bathsheba and Uriah,
         both there in the ancestry story of Jesus.
 
Matthew won’t let the victims
         be written out of the record.
 
At the root of the Messiah’s family
         is the memory of a loyal foreigner who was killed
         and a woman who was taken.
 
The story of grace is told
         with the wrong still visible.
 
 
That, I think, is what we’ve been given this morning.
 
Not a God who looks away,
         and not a God who looks only to condemn.
 
But a God who sees clearly what we’d rather keep in shadow —
         “the thing that David had done” —
         and who sees it with steadfast love.
 
David passes a death sentence on himself.
 
And once he’s confessed,
         Nathan’s very next words are:
“The Lord has put away your sin;
         you shall not die” (12.13).
 
There are still consequences,
         and the rest of David’s story is grim with them.
 
But the verdict we pronounce on ourselves —
         and the one we’re so quick to pronounce on others,
                  as the tenants did —
         isn’t God’s last word.
 
So when we’re found out —
         by a prophet,
         by a story,
by a colleague who won’t stay quiet,
         by the slow, honest work of our own consciences —
we’re not being found out
         by a God who’s waiting to destroy us.
 
We’re being found by a God
         whose seeing is already mercy.
 
The truth that says “you are the man”
         is the same truth that says “you shall not die”.
 
The God who searches us and knows us
         is the God who creates in us a clean heart
         and puts a new and right spirit within us (51.10).
 
We are seen,
         all the way down.
 
We are loved,
         all the way down.
 
The stone the builders rejected
         has become the cornerstone.
 
This was the Lord’s doing,
         and it is amazing in our eyes.
 
Amen.

Tuesday, 6 October 2026

The Missing Line

A Sermon for Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church,
Sunday 11 October 2026



Exodus 19.3–7; 20.1–17
Matthew 5.17
 
If some of us have a nagging sense of déjà vu this morning,
          we're not imagining it.
 
Back in August we spent our summer series
          on the Ten Commandments,
          and now, barely two months later,
          the lectionary has marched us straight back up Sinai.
 
It's tempting to think
          somebody wasn't looking at the preaching plan.
 
Those of us who missed a week or two in August
          because we were away
          can at least take comfort:
          after the sermon on the Sabbath,
          that probably counts as obedience.
 
But the Bible got there first.
          The commandments are given twice:
          once here in Exodus,
          and then again in Deuteronomy,
 
when Moses stands before the next generation
          on the edge of the promised land
          and goes through the whole lot again.
 
And as he does, he says something remarkable:
          "Not with our ancestors did the LORD make this covenant,
          but with us, who are all of us here alive today"
          (Deuteronomy 5.3).
 
The commandments aren't a syllabus
          we complete and tick off.
          They're meant to be heard again and again,
          until we hear them as spoken to us,
          now.
 
Israel was told to talk about them
          at home and away,
          when lying down and when rising up
          (Deuteronomy 6.7).
 
By that standard,
          two months between sermons is a bit slack.
 
And there's something interesting
          about that second telling.
 
In Exodus,
          the reason given for the Sabbath is creation.
          In Deuteronomy, Moses gives a different reason:
          "Remember that you were a slave in the land of Egypt"
          (Deuteronomy 5.15).
 
When the commandments are repeated,
          the memory of Egypt doesn't shrink;
          it grows.
 
That's worth holding on to,
          because not every repetition of the commandments
          does that.
 
 
In classrooms across Louisiana and Texas this term,
          children are sitting underneath a poster.
 
The law says it has to be a decent size,
          and it says exactly what the poster must contain.
 
It's the Ten Commandments,
          in the old King James wording,
          and it begins like this:
          "I AM the LORD thy God."
          Full stop.
 
Then straight on to
          "Thou shalt have no other gods before me."
 
Something's gone.
          In the Bible that first sentence doesn't stop there.
 
It carries on:
          "I am the LORD thy God,
          which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt,
          out of the house of bondage."
 
Somewhere between Sinai and the state legislature,
          that line was cut.
          Somebody decided it wasn't needed.
 
Now, before we get too comfortable
          tutting at America,
          it's worth remembering
          that we've done this too.
 
In 1604 the Church of England ordered
          that the Ten Commandments be set up
          at the east end of every parish church,
          where the people could best see and read them.
 
Plenty of those boards are still there,
          gold lettering on black.
 
They went up in a church established by law,
          in a country where Baptists and other dissenters
          could be fined or locked up
          for meeting on their own terms.
 
Within a few years Thomas Helwys,
          one of the very first English Baptists,
          had written to King James to remind him
          that "the king is a mortal man, and not God,
          therefore hath no power over the immortal souls of his subjects".
 
He died in Newgate prison
          for his trouble.
 
There's a pattern here.
          Whenever the commandments get taken up
          by the powers that be,
          the first thing to go
          is the story.
 
The law that set slaves free
          gets turned into a rule
          for keeping people in their place.
 
And the line that goes missing,
          every time,
          is the one about Egypt.
 
So this morning
          let's put it back.
 
 
The story starts, in Exodus 19,
          not with a command
          but with a memory.
 
The people have been out of Egypt for three months,
          and they're camped at the foot of a mountain
          in the middle of nowhere.
 
Before a single word of law is spoken,
          God tells Moses to remind them of something:
 
"You have seen what I did to the Egyptians,
          and how I bore you on eagles' wings
          and brought you to myself"
          (Exodus 19.4).
 
Notice what it doesn't say.
          It doesn't say "I brought you to this mountain",
          or even "I brought you to the promised land".
 
It says "I brought you to myself".
          The destination of the exodus
          isn't a place;
          it's a relationship.
 
Grace comes first.
          The rules come second,
          and they come as the shape of a love
          that's already been given.
 
So when the next verse says
          "if you obey my voice and keep my covenant"
          (Exodus 19.5),
          that "if" isn't a price of admission.
 
They're already out.
          The "if" is about how to stay free,
          not how to get free.
 
And then there's the eagle,
          the bird of empire.
 
Rome's legions marched behind it,
          and empires have liked eagles
          ever since.
 
But in the Bible
          the eagle's wings belong to God,
          and they're used for carrying people away from empire,
          not marching them into it.
 
When the Book of Revelation
          wants to describe God's people escaping the dragon,
          it borrows this image straight from Exodus:
 
"the woman was given the two wings of the great eagle,
          so that she could fly from the serpent
          into the wilderness"
          (Revelation 12.14).
 
Both times,
          the eagle carries people out into the wilderness,
          which is where a people
          learns how to be free.
 
And then God says one more thing
          before the commandments begin:
          "you shall be for me a priestly kingdom
          and a holy nation"
          (Exodus 19.6).
 
In Egypt,
          one man stood between the people and the gods,
          and that was Pharaoh.
 
Here the whole people is priestly.
          Nobody gets to stand over anybody else.
 
Baptists have been saying something like that
          for four hundred years.
 
 
The Israelites at Sinai
          already knew all about law.
 
Pharaoh had law.
          Pharaoh had quotas.
 
Make this many bricks.
          Now make the same number of bricks
          without the straw.
 
And when they asked for a few days
          to go into the wilderness and worship,
          Pharaoh's answer was:
          "You are lazy, lazy"
          (Exodus 5.17).
 
Pharaoh's law had no rest in it,
          no limit,
          and no end.
 
So when God gives law at Sinai,
          it's a counter-law.
 
And we can hear Pharaoh being answered,
          commandment by commandment.
 
"You shall have no other gods before me."
          Pharaoh claimed to be a god.
 
So the very first commandment
          is a political statement
          as much as a religious one:
          nobody who holds power over us
          is God.
 
The ban on idols goes further:
          idolatry is what happens
          whenever we take something we've built,
          an economy, an institution, a flag,
          and serve it as though it were ultimate.
 
The commandments begin
          by clearing away every false god,
          because false gods always demand sacrifices,
          and it's never the powerful
          who end up on the altar.
 
Then there's the Sabbath.
          One day in seven,
          nobody works.
 
Not you,
          not your son or your daughter,
          and then the list keeps going:
 
"your male or female slave, your livestock,
          or the alien resident in your towns"
          (Exodus 20.10).
 
A nation of former slaves is being told
          that they may never do to others
          what was done to them.
 
Rest isn't earned.
          It's something everybody gets,
          and it's shared all the way down,
          to the servant, to the ox,
          and to the stranger.
 
It's the first labour law in the Bible,
          and it's more generous
          than many of ours.
 
So the stranger is right there
          in the middle of the Ten Commandments,
          and later Exodus makes it explicit:
 
"You shall not wrong or oppress a resident alien,
          for you were aliens in the land of Egypt"
          (Exodus 22.21).
 
The missing line
          again.
 
 
It's hard to read that
          without thinking about Britain this autumn.
 
Since March,
          anyone recognised as a refugee in this country
          is given thirty months of protection
          rather than five years,
 
and at the end of each thirty months
          their case is looked at again.
 
On top of that,
          the government has proposed
          that the road to settling here permanently
          could stretch to twenty years.
 
The name for this new arrangement
          is "core protection".
 
Think about what that means
          for a human being.
 
Someone flees a regime
          that wanted them dead.
 
They're examined,
          they're believed,
          they're officially recognised as a refugee.
 
And then they're told
          that for the next two decades,
          every two and a half years,
          they'll have to prove it all over again.
 
They can't quite set down roots.
          They can't quite plan.
          They can't quite rest.
 
It's a life without a Sabbath.
          It's the house of bondage
          rebuilt as a waiting room.
 
Some of us here know that waiting room
          from the inside,
          and some of us have sat alongside friends
          who've been waiting for the next letter
          from the Home Office.
 
We're not here to point fingers
          at people who are anxious about migration;
          those anxieties are real,
          and they're being exploited
          by people who ought to know better.
 
But we are here to say
          that a politics which turns insecurity into policy
          has forgotten the line about Egypt.
 
When a nation forgets
          that it was ever the stranger,
          it starts building the very thing
          it once escaped.
 
 
There's one more commandment
          worth lingering over,
          and that's the last one.
 
"You shall not covet your neighbour's house;
          you shall not covet your neighbour's wife,
          or male or female slave, or ox, or donkey,
          or anything that belongs to your neighbour"
          (Exodus 20.17).
 
It's a strange one,
          because it's the only commandment
          about something that happens inside us.
 
You can't see coveting,
          and no court can prosecute it.
 
And yet
          it's where the whole list has been heading.
 
The commandments climb.
          Don't murder.
          Don't commit adultery.
          Don't steal.
 
Don't bear false witness.
          And then the tenth
          goes underneath all of them,
          down to the root.
 
Why do we kill,
          and cheat, and steal,
          and lie about each other?
 
Because we want what our neighbour has.
          Often we want it
          precisely because our neighbour has it.
 
Our desires are borrowed.
          We learn what to want
          by watching each other,
 
and before long the neighbour who taught us to want
          becomes the rival
          standing in our way.
 
That's where violence comes from.
          It's as old as Cain and Abel.
 
Empires are just coveting at scale.
          Pharaoh's slaves were building store cities
          (Exodus 1.11),
          warehouses for surplus,
          monuments to more,
 
and an economy that runs on endless wanting
          will always need somebody
          to make the bricks.
 
So the tenth commandment
          isn't a fussy little rule about envy.
 
It names the engine
          that drives the whole house of bondage,
          and switches it off.
 
 
Which brings us to Jesus,
          sitting on another mountain.
 
"Do not think that I have come
          to abolish the law or the prophets;
          I have come not to abolish
          but to fulfil"
          (Matthew 5.17).
 
Christians have too often read this
          as Jesus dismantling a religion of law
          and replacing it with a religion of grace.
          That's not what he says.
 
He's a Jewish teacher,
          teaching Jewish people,
          and he tells them the law
          isn't going anywhere.
 
Besides,
          the grace was there at Sinai
          before the law was.
          It was there on eagles' wings.
 
To fulfil something
          is to fill it full,
          to give it its whole weight.
 
And if we read on in Matthew 5,
          we can see how Jesus does it.
 
"You have heard that it was said
          to those of ancient times,
          'You shall not murder'...
 
but I say to you
          that if you are angry with a brother or sister,
          you will be liable to judgement."
 
He follows each commandment
          down to the root,
          to the anger and the wanting underneath.
 
He does with every commandment
          what the tenth was already doing.
 
But there's another way
          Jesus fulfils the law.
 
When Jesus stands before Pilate,
          the religious authorities say:
 
"We have a law,
          and according to that law
          he ought to die"
          (John 19.7).
 
There it is again.
          Law with the exodus line cut out.
 
Law in the hands of temple power
          and Roman power,
          working together
          to get rid of a troublemaker.
 
Law used as a weapon,
          not a gift.
 
And on Easter morning
          God overturns the verdict.
 
The resurrection is God's judgement
          on every use of law
          to crush the innocent.
 
God doesn't side with the court;
          God sides with the condemned.
 
The one the law put to death
          is the one God raises to life.
 
That's the fulfilment.
          In Jesus,
          the missing line is restored.
 
"I am the Lord your God,
          who brought you out of the land of Egypt,
          out of the house of slavery"
 
becomes, on Easter Day,
          "I am the Lord your God,
          who brought you out of the grave."
 
The God of the exodus
          is the God of the empty tomb.
 
The commandments were always meant
          to be read in that light:
          as the shape of life
          for people who've been carried out.
 
 
In a moment we'll sing
          "We limit not the truth of God
          to our poor reach of mind."
 
It's built on the words of John Robinson,
          pastor to English Separatists
          exiled in the Netherlands,
 
who told his people in 1620
          that the Lord had yet more light and truth
          to break forth from his word.
 
Which is another way of saying
          that when we come back to the same texts,
          we never come back
          to quite the same place.
 
So here's the truth this morning,
          and it's not a task.
          It's a gift.
 
We've been carried.
          Whatever house of bondage
          any of us has known,
          whether it was a regime,
          or an addiction,
 
or a debt we never chose,
          or a waiting room
          that seemed to have no end,
 
the God who bore Israel on eagles' wings
          has borne us too.
 
We've been brought,
          not just somewhere,
          but to God.
 
We're a priestly people,
          every one of us,
          with nobody standing over anybody else.
 
Our rest is not earned.
          It's given,
          and it's given to the stranger
          as much as to us.
 
And the commandments
          aren't the price of our freedom.
          They're what freedom looks like
          when it's shared.
 
The first line belongs to us.
          Nobody can cut it out.
 
"I am the Lord your God,
          who brought you out of the land of Egypt,
          out of the house of slavery."
 
That's where the law begins.
          And that's where we begin,
          too.